Tuesday, July 7, 2009

Comments on National policy on Open Standards on E-governance

Here I am writing my comments on 3rd draft (version 2.0) of "National Policy on Open Standards for e-Governance, dated May 26, 2009"


1 Shri Shankar Aggarwal, Joint Secretary (e-Governance)
Department of Information Technology
2. Mr. Som Mittal, President, NASSCOM,
3. Vinnie Mehta, Executive Director
Manufacturers' Association for Information Technology (MAIT)

Sub : Comments on National policy on Open Standards on E-governance

Dear Sirs,

I have gone through the 3rd draft (version 2.0) of "National Policy on Open Standards for e-Governance, dated May 26, 2009" and I am enclosing my comments after reviewing it.

Para 6.1.4 -
I welcome that the policy document support "Open Standard".

    But as per para 6.1.4 - The final decision goes in the hand of "Apex Body on e-governance Standard". This can be a loop-hole where Govt of India may follow multiple standards. Policy document must enforce that the decision process

  • must be transparent and

  • "Apex Body" must give decision favoring single standard from the multiple competing standards.

Having multiple standards is not only dangerous but also a self contradictory term.

Section 6.2
In the case of Non-availability of standards, Govt of India must not adopt any of alternate standard no matter they are temporary, because of following reasons

  • The time period of alternate standard is not defined.

  • This may lead to multiple standards on time line. It would be difficult to convert data and information between two time periods. Every govt may change the standard for temporal basic and would further lead to loss of meaning standards.

  • In the digital world, standard may not always compatible with each other. For example, you cannot convert one file with closed proprietary standard into the alternate open standard. If the closed and proprietary standard got chosen for a finite time of period, It will be difficult to convert files and documents to new open standard in future. This would lead to many difficulties.

  • As per 6.2.1, 6.2.2 and 6.2.3, relaxing the mandatory conditions will dilute the whole standardization process. Standards must be "open" , "patent free" and "royalty free". All data of Govt of India belongs of public and we cannot store the data on format which is not open or royalty-free.

  • If there arise a condition where “Govt of India” is unable to find any suitable standard in a particular domain, Govt of India must initiate a process of creating a corresponding Open Standard using public reviews and RFCs.

Section 6.4
Govt of India must not support multiple standards in particular domains. There is no meaning of a having standardization process which is itself leading to more then one standard. Section 6.4 allow multiple standards. The objections are as follows:

  • Adopting multiple standards will complicate the process of “information exchange” and “conversion” from one standard to another.

  • Adopting multiple standard is as good as having no standard in place.

  • There is no limit on number of multiple standards.

Yours sincerely,

Narendra Sisodiya
Coordinator, Linux User Group of IIT Delhi
Contact - +91 - 9312166995

Click here to get its pdf file

Other links :

1) http://osindia.blogspot.com/2009/07/last-minute-dramas-around-around-open.html

2) http://lists.fosscom.in/pipermail/network-fosscom.in/2009-July/000346.html

Monday, June 29, 2009

My First Laptop

Hi, I want to to tell you about my laptop purchase and its decision process. Firstly I wanted to have laptop for programming, music and communication purpose. Initially I wanted to have 'Gateway' refurbished laptop in india. in Gateway i can have Turion 64 bit, 3GB DDR2/3. 320 GB at 25,000. But it is very difficult to get a Gateway lappy in India, unless one of your friend is coming back to india and he can buy for you. After searching a lot online, I decided go to local market, Nehru Place. NP is india biggest grey market. I went to all showrooms but unable to find suitable AMD turion 64 bit model. because I use GNU/linux, I can utilise full advantage of 64 bit processor and OS. Finally I decided to buy Intel based laptop. people have misconception about processor speed and they often try to buy the latest processor and the price difference between 2.0 GHz and 2.2 GHz contain difference of 1000 to 2000 INR. frankly speaking, by speed, 2.0 and 2.8 will not produce any significant speed difference. Speed comes from RAM speed. So I decided to buy DDR3 based RAM. Again people think that 4GB is better then 2B RAM. in most of the case, the RAM utilisation is just around 1-2GB or less. even I never found any use of swap space. So I decided to stick with 2GB DDR3 RAM. I wanted to have storage of 320 GB. Now comes to features. Most of the people never go to see what exactly are the features they are getting. The most important feature is Sound. You are supposed to listen movies and sounds. For my laptop i decided to have Dolby digital sound. The next feature is connectivity, Gigabit LAN and 802.11 N* support wifi and bluethooth. Do you believe I was able to get all these configuration within 29,500 from Nehru Place. Let me tell you the model number I selected Acer Aspire 4736z. Here is the full configuration of my laptop.

  • Intel Pentium Dual Core T4200 processor (1MB L2 cacahe,2GHz,800 MHz FSB)
  • Mobile Intel GL40 express chipset
  • 2GB DDR3 RAM, 1067 MHz
  • 320GB Hard Disk Space, 5400 RPM
  • Super Multi DVD writer
  • 14.1-inch HD Acer CineCrystal LED-Backlit TFT screen
  • Dolby Surround sound
  • 1366×768 resolution
  • Acer CrystalEye Webcam, 1.3 MP
  • Wi-Fi 802.11 b/g/n
  • Gigabit Lan
  • HDMI
  • 5-in-1 card reader
  • 3 USB v2.0 ports
  • 1 year international warranty

Thursday, May 7, 2009

A vision for Free of Cost IIT/AIEEE educational contents

Today and before 10 year too, We Indians started dreaming for so called big college and IITs and student like me has invested full money for coaching. Today more then 10 lakh students gave AIEEE exam. Today getting coaching for these exam is more expensive then college itself. I always advocate for collaborative shared learning. But I have a question that can have some free of cost IIT/AIEEE coaching?
Yes it is possible. These is a need of change the system a little bit. We need to understand of power of collaboration. We need to setup a Non-Profit organisation to generate the educational contents for such exam preparation. If we consider physics , chemistry , math and biology as major subject then these can be taught in 1 year at 6 hour daily in regular classroom. If 1000 student come to give their contribution toward making free of cost , publicly distributed educational material, we can make a good educational content within a month. All you need to divide topics and study well for your topic. After getting mastery you just need to present it in one day. This process take 1 week per student to create 1 video lecture. 1000 student can create 1000 episodes in a week, and in a month we can have 4000 episode educational content. This need donations too. because we need recording and publishing facility. Every videos will be delivered in public domain where i can be utilised in any way you want. I wish I could start something like this very soon.

Sunday, April 26, 2009

Some thoughts on Education System

Being an Indian from grounds and having interest in Education , I learned that no hi-fi teachers are required in education system. Student can/should learn by them self. which is the best way. Only small pointer is required for learning. Syllabus and tutorials are good pointers. Teacher is required just for small guidance. We are now living in the era of networked Internet and wikipedia type collaboration tools. Now students should start understand the power of "viral ,globally shared and collaborative learning". If students are feeling something is needed then they can work locally to make that possible,,and not waiting for teacher or policy to correct them, (for example a Linux repo in IIT Delhi came in 2007, just because student tried their effort at 2007 with all odds)
we cannot just blame education system infrastructure and teacher,,,,, there just need of pointer,

If there is a need to improve education system, it lies at the school (class 1st to 8th), As they learn "rattafication" there and they never get taste in education and learning.
please revisit the terms -- viral, globally shared and collaborative learning. It is better if you have internet connectivity, but if you do not have internet connectivity the same thing can be done in group and shared way of learning. We started LUG workshop just to test how and upto what level we can collaborate and how we can more productive using this.

If you say, you do not have good teacher, I should say u are not a good student. I expressed my primarily concerns on school children. The "base" of a school child is not well, If he/she need tuition's at 1st class then he/she will need forever. I am saying just study by yourself. I am saying,, do not depends on teacher. Depends on you and collaborative group study locally. Collaboration is one of primary ethics of study.
We need to build up a strong base level foundation in students.
After an unsuccessful attempt of IIT-JEE, I remembered in college days when I was in first year, I started teaching (as tutor) for 11th and 12th class. But every student in my district use to run away from the first class of vector algebra. The guy who just passed 10th somehow do not know basic of algebra and equations, How can I teach such guys. In the whole district I was able to find just 2 guys who can study at the IIT level under me. The most important thing we need to develop the ideals in the mind of student that they should learn first and give the exam, otherwise getting 35 marks and study ahead is just waste. A person who is weak in math at 10th will not be able to cover math in 11th and 12th. So we need to focus on learning rather then timely passing.

When I learned height and distance in lower class, I tried to measure actual height of buildings. Do students have such practical thinking in his mind? Do you need teacher to give you assignments and then u will think for practicals ?
You can make microscope in less then 20 RS and everything is in book. Have u tried ???
You may surprised to know, once I rejected to give my exam paper in BE , just because it was a important subject in GATE exam and I have not done its study well ! Will we ever be able to develops such ideal in little minds.

Let me again come to schools. Now a days the horrible danger came in middle class society --- English Convent School. everywhere we can see such schools and teacher at such schools are paid just less then 1000 rs per month. Atlest in our time when the text books was in hindi we can atleast understand that what goes on the pages of books and what in written and their meaning. My bhanja (son of sister) Harshit is 9 year old and he is a part of good convent school. last month when I visited him, my sister was forcing him to study and was trying the "rattafication" of some sentences. Those sentence were marked by school teacher and paper will come from these marked sentences. he was again and again repeating - "The earth revolves around the sun" but he do not know the actual meaning of that sentences. It is not just a story of Harshit, this happens with all children and all subjects.

The worst part I observed in students is they are lazy to correct the system. Students are part of education, my dear if you blame and thing something to be included then go ahead and try to make a change what you like, last time i gave a example of LUG repo at IITD. We thought and we worked and now everybody know what is 10,10.4.1/linux and lug-iitd.org articles. If you think there is not a good library in ur city at your time of education then -- donate your books or after getting good salary donate 10,000 Rs to your village/city. 100 such donations can make a good library.
if you think u do not have good books then write it or give feedback to publishers.
If you think you have solved some problem differently then just blog it or share it in some electronic media. I have so many math/physics tricks in mind but mostly they are waste because I cannot share it as i am no longer a tutor now but still I try to write articles on my blogs-- for example , I somehow know proof of mechanics equations in vector form, I have not found these proof on Internet , so i just wrote them here -- http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:Narendra_Sisodiya/mechanics If u see from my point of view then it is just a waste of time, Why should one waste time to blog/share. The answer is , Think globally. Think it as ecosystem. If everybody share so learning will be more effective and fact.

I want to conclude that -- Do no just blame on teacher,,think there are zero teacher in India.

First be good student and have studentship with education ethics in your pocket. At the same time just do not pass from one class to other class somehow without learning. or in other words, There is no place for shortcuts in education system , you need to "love to learn".

Let our children explore better this world by good books. The school age is the foundation age so i was strongly suggested for its improvement. Only at school age teacher are needed to make them good human being and student. coursework they can learn by themself too. As far as motivation is required, books are best thing. Ask child to read about great persons. This is motivate them through out the life. Ask child to watch good TV programs like NetGeo junior etc. I remember when we was child we use to watch CIET Tarang , Turning Point, Surbhi, etc. I use to watch Prof Yashpal at that time. Those days on DD1 and DD2 are available. It is difficult to measure that how TV and books can play role in our life. but the truth is , when we are child, these TV, books and social culture make a solid and hidden impact on subconscious mind. as i can say - I am what i have seen. our child age define our "base class", whole life is derived class of it. So Ishan, this is the way how you can give motivation and thought process.

I agree that if there is a good teacher then student will learn a lot but the problem is that , ratio of teacher to students is highly unequal. and this ration will never become proper. so only solution depends on students itself. which is what I have shown in last post.which is very obvious path of collaborative self learning. Self learning theory was mainly for grown up student but I can give example that a small child at age 9 also very craetive. Let me put Bhanja Story again. [these are real stories of my life]

1st instance, Hemant , just 10 year old boy can play mobile very well and he use to change language and many things. My father is a govt teacher and 50 year old do not know how to operate mobile properly. This happens with all child, they can very good at self learning. this may them very happy. Hemant and Hansa (6 year old) , use to record audio and playback later for fun and dance. The knowlede the Hemant automatically shared to Hansa also.
conclusion :
children are very creative and believe on collaborative learning too. and they can very well self learn too.

2nd instance. I have installed fedora 8 on my home PC. Harshit only use to play games. I cannot download games due to low bandwidth, so I shown him how to google search for 'flash games'. After 2-3 days not only he can start the desktop at his own, but he was able to google search many new terms and play game by himself. Many time he use to put "Cartoon Network" characters names to pic and videos. In search result he automatically discovered youtube and also watch cartoon by himself. One day I found very strange thing, the desktop background was changed. I never shown his how to do this but his has changed the desktop background and I was very surprised.
conclusion : children are very creative

Saturday, March 7, 2009

Shame on Indian Government

Mahatma Gandhi is one of the greatest personality ever found in world's history. Today our Indian Government should feel a shame that they are no having $1.8 million to purchase Gandhi's items on auction. They are raising their votes with Gandhi's photos from long time and they are unable to purchase the items in action. Vijay Mallya said that he was not bidding on behalf on government. He said - "bid for the country". He was not govt representative.

This is a failure of our Indian Govt. India has potential to become a developed country but this can happen when we should vote to the right person.

Saturday, November 29, 2008

Gtalk status message of kartikey Bhaiya

We living in Mumbai are a scared lot, please spare us the chorus of "mumbai ka jazba" no we dont have any jazba but a freaking sick majboori to keep going in our life. please spare a thought about us who dont know if we will come back alive while going out for work. we are one of the most hardworking folks but no please dont keep testing our jazba, because each time one of us dies we are left poorer by another common man who had no option. may god give us the strength to kill and kill brutally these basterd

Thursday, October 16, 2008

Don is coming back to Delhi,

Dear All,
So, Finally I am coming back to Delhi at 24 oct 2008. Hope I will carry my all activities with same enthusiasm. I specially thanks many of my friends who were the driving force for this transfer.

Narendra Sisodiya